Paper: arXiv 2405.12768

Abstract

Many active funds hold concentrated portfolios. Flow-driven trading in these securities causes price pressure, which pushes up the funds’ existing positions resulting in realized returns. We decompose fund returns into a price pressure (self-inflated) and a fundamental component and show that when allocating capital across funds, investors are unable to identify whether realized returns are self-inflated or fundamental. Because investors chase self-inflated fund returns at a high frequency, even short-lived impact meaningfully affects fund flows at longer time scales. The combination of price impact and return chasing causes an endogenous feedback loop and a reallocation of wealth to early fund investors, which unravels once the price pressure reverts. We find that flows chasing self-inflated returns predict bubbles in ETFs and their subsequent crashes, and lead to a daily wealth reallocation of 500 Million from ETFs alone. We provide a simple regulatory reporting measure – fund illiquidity – which captures a fund’s potential for self-inflated returns.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 4.0/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 8.5/10
  • Quadrant: Street Traders — practical and empirical, lighter on theory

Why this score: The paper relies on robust empirical analysis with detailed data on fund flows and portfolio holdings, and provides a concrete regulatory measure, but the mathematical models are relatively straightforward decompositions without heavy derivations.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal: Decompose fund returns into price pressure vs. fundamental value"] --> B["Methodology"]
  B --> C{"Key Inputs"}
  C --> D["Fund Holdings & Returns Data"]
  C --> E["ETF Flow Data"]
  B --> F["Computational Process: Decomposition & Feedback Loop Analysis"]
  D & E --> F
  F --> G["Key Findings/Outcomes"]
  G --> H["Price Pressure Effect: Self-inflated returns drive flows"]
  G --> I["Feedback Loop: Return chasing creates bubble/crash cycles"]
  G --> J["Wealth Reallocation: $500M daily shift from ETFs"]

Cited References (88)

  1. Do ETFs increase volatility? (2018)
  2. Intraday arbitrage between ETFs and their underlying portfolios (2021)
  3. Dissecting cross-impact on stock markets: An empirical analysis (2017)
  4. Two Centuries of Trend Following (2014)
  5. Market liquidity and funding liquidity (2009)
  6. Running for the exit: distressed selling and endogenous correlation in financial markets (2013)
  7. Impact-adjusted valuation and the criticality of leverage (2012)
  8. Large bets and stock market crashes (2023)
and 80 more
  1. What happened to the quants in August 2007? Evidence from factors and transactions data (2011)
  2. How to build a cross-impact model from first principles: Theoretical requirements and empirical results (2022)
  3. The inelastic market hypothesis: a microstructural interpretation (2022)
  4. Slow decay of impact in equity markets: insights from the ANcerno database (2018)
  5. An analysis of the implications for stock and futures price volatility of program trading and dynamic hedging strategies (1987)
  6. Returns to buying winners and selling losers: Implications for stock market efficiency (1993)
  7. Cross-sectional and time-series determinants of momentum returns (2002)
  8. Momentum strategies (1996)
  9. Mutual fund flows and performance in rational markets (2004)
  10. The flow-performance relationship around the world (2012)
  11. Investor flows and fragility in corporate bond funds (2017)
  12. Participation costs and the sensitivity of fund flows to past performance (2007)
  13. Consumer reaction to measures of poor quality: Evidence from the mutual fund industry (1992)
  14. Active fundamental performance (2018)
  15. Assessing asset pricing models using revealed preference (2016)
  16. Swing pricing and fragility in open-end mutual funds (2022)
  17. Financial fragility in the COVID-19 crisis: The case of investment funds in corporate bond markets (2021)
  18. Costly search and mutual fund flows (1998)
  19. Risk taking by mutual funds as a response to incentives (1997)
  20. Competition for Attention in the ETF Space (2023)
  21. Product differentiation, search costs, and competition in the mutual fund industry: A case study of S&P 500 index funds (2004)
  22. ETF activity and informational efficiency of underlying securities (2021)
  23. Flow (2019)
  24. Which factors matter to investors? Evidence from mutual fund flows (2016)
  25. The mismatch between mutual fund scale and skill (2020)
  26. Trades, quotes and prices: financial markets under the microscope (2018)
  27. A flow-based explanation for return predictability (2012)
  28. How active is your fund manager? A new measure that predicts performance (2009)
  29. The performance of mutual funds in the period 1945-1964 (1968)
  30. On persistence in mutual fund performance (1997)
  31. Mutual fund performance and seemingly unrelated assets (2002)
  32. Judging fund managers by the company they keep (2005)
  33. A demand system approach to asset pricing (2019)
  34. In search of the origins of financial fluctuations: The inelastic markets hypothesis (2021)
  35. Which investors matter for equity valuations and expected returns? (2020)
  36. Institutional corporate bond pricing (2022)
  37. How competitive is the stock market? theory, evidence from portfolios, and implications for the rise of passive investing (2021)
  38. The real effects of financial markets: The impact of prices on takeovers (2012)
  39. Mutual fund trading pressure: Firm-level stock price impact and timing of SEOs (2012)
  40. Benchmarking intensity (2023)
  41. Is there too much benchmarking in asset management? (2023)
  42. Why do demand curves for stocks slope down? (2009)
  43. Short-and long-term demand curves for stocks: theory and evidence on the dynamics of arbitrage (2005)
  44. Presidential address: Asset price dynamics with slow-moving capital (2010)
  45. Identifying the price impact of fire sales using high-frequency surprise mutual fund flows (2020)
  46. Extrapolative beliefs in the cross-section: What can we learn from the crowds? (2021)
  47. Expectations of returns and expected returns (2014)
  48. X-CAPM: An extrapolative capital asset pricing model (2015)
  49. Empirical market microstructure: The institutions, economics, and econometrics of securities trading (2007)
  50. Do demand curves for stocks slope down? (1986)
  51. The price of immediacy (2008)
  52. Regression discontinuity and the price effects of stock market indexing (2015)
  53. Advice-driven demand and systematic price fluctuations (2020)
  54. Institutional Corporate Bond Pricing (2020)
  55. Does arbitrage flatten demand curves for stocks? (2002)
  56. Long-term Investors, Demand Shifts, and Yields (2021)
  57. Spillover effects of payouts on asset prices and real investment (2022)
  58. Issuer quality and corporate bond returns (2013)
  59. Stock market stimulus (2023)
  60. Price and volume effects associated with changes in the S&P 500 list: New evidence for the existence of price pressures (1986)
  61. The price response to S&P 500 index additions and deletions: Evidence of asymmetry and a new explanation (2004)
  62. Asset fire sales (and purchases) in equity markets (2007)
  63. How investors interpret past fund returns (2003)
  64. Of tournaments and temptations: An analysis of managerial incentives in the mutual fund industry (1996)
  65. Mutual fund risk and market share-adjusted fund flows (2013)
  66. Dumb money: Mutual fund flows and the cross-section of stock returns (2008)
  67. Stock price fragility (2011)
  68. Bubbles for fama (2019)
  69. Fund tradeoffs (2020)
  70. Market microstructure invariance: Empirical hypotheses (2016)
  71. What drives the size and value factors? (2022)
  72. Trading costs (2018)
  73. Anomalous price impact and the critical nature of liquidity in financial markets (2011)
  74. Predictable price pressure (2022)
  75. Active portfolio management (2000)
  76. Institutional investors and stock market volatility (2006)
  77. Nonbank fragility in credit markets: Evidence from a two-layer asset demand system (2022)
  78. On the impossibility of informationally efficient markets (1980)
  79. Corporate bond multipliers: Substitutes matter (2022)
  80. Prices are less elastic for less diversifiable demand (2022)

0 of 88 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2518 linked papers.