Paper: arXiv 2507.07358

Authors: Jennifer Alonso-Garcia, Len Patrick Dominic M. Garces, Jonathan Ziveyi

Abstract

This paper investigates optimal withdrawal strategies and behavior of policyholders in a variable annuity (VA) contract with a guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit (GMWB) rider incorporating taxation and a ratchet mechanism for enhancing the benefit base during the life of the contract. Mathematically, this is accomplished by solving a backward dynamic programming problem associated with optimizing the discounted risk-neutral expectation of cash flows from the contract. Furthermore, reflecting traded VA contracts in the market, we consider hybrid products providing policyholders access to a cash fund which functions as an intermediate repository of earnings from the VA and earns interest at a contractually specified cash rate. We contribute to the literature by revealing several significant interactions among taxation, the cash fund, and the benefit base update mechanism. When tax rates are high, the tax-shielding effect of the cash fund, which is taxed differently from ordinary withdrawals from the VA, plays a significant role in enhancing the attractiveness of the overall contract. Furthermore, the ratchet benefit base update scheme (in contrast to the ubiquitous return-of-premium specification in the literature) tends to discourage early surrender as it provides enhanced downside market risk protection. In addition, the cash fund discourages active withdrawals, with policyholders preferring to transfer the guaranteed withdrawal amount to the cash fund to leverage the cash fund rate.

Complexity vs Empirical Score

  • Math Complexity: 7.5/10
  • Empirical Rigor: 3.0/10
  • Quadrant: Lab Rats — theoretically deep, empirically untested

Why this score: The paper uses advanced mathematical techniques like backward dynamic programming and risk-neutral valuation to solve an optimal stopping problem, resulting in a high math score. However, the empirical evidence is primarily theoretical and relies on numerical experiments rather than real-world backtesting or heavy data implementation, leading to a low empirical rigor score.

Research Flowchart

  flowchart TD
  A["Research Goal:<br>Optimal Withdrawal Strategy<br>for Variable Annuities with GMWB<br>considering Taxation & Ratchet Mechanism"] --> B["Methodology:<br>Backward Dynamic Programming"]
  
  B --> C["Key Inputs & Data:"]
  C --> C1["Contract Design:<br>Ratchet vs Return-of-Premium"]
  C --> C2["Taxation Parameters:<br>Tax Rates & Cash Fund Rules"]
  C --> C3["Market Variables:<br>Interest Rates & Asset Returns"]
  
  C --> D["Computational Process:<br>Risk-Neutral Expectation<br>Maximization"]
  
  D --> E["Key Findings & Outcomes:"]
  E --> E1["Tax-Shielding Effect:<br>Cash fund enhances attractiveness<br>under high tax rates"]
  E --> E2["Ratchet Mechanism:<br>Reduces early surrender<br>via downside protection"]
  E --> E3["Behavioral Impact:<br>Cash fund discourages active<br>withdrawals (transfers preferred)"]

Cited References (108)

  1. Valuing variable annuities with path-dependent surrender guarantees under regime-switching L'evy models (2023) — link
  2. Pricing and hedging guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefits under a general L'evy framework using the COS method (2018) — link
  3. Taxation and policyholder behavior: the case of guaranteed minimum accumulation benefits (2020) — link
  4. A hybrid variable annuity contract embedded with living and death benefit riders (2022) — link
  5. Taxation and policyholder behavior: the case of guaranteed minimum accumulation benefits (2024) — link
  6. A two-account pricing framework for hybrid variable annuity contract embedded with living and death benefit riders (2026) — link
  7. Cross-hedging minimum return guarantees: Basis and liquidity risks (2014) — link
  8. The existence of optimal bang-bang controls for GMxB contracts (2015) — link
and 100 more
  1. Variable annuities: A unifying valuation approach (2011) — link
  2. The valuation of GMWB variable annuities under alternative fund distributions and policyholder behaviours (2016) — link
  3. Taxing Pensions: the Australian approach (2018)
  4. A universal pricing framework for guaranteed minimum benefits in variable annuities (2008) — link
  5. Cheaper by the bundle: The interaction of frictions and option exercise in variable annuities (2023) — link
  6. Policyholder exercise behavior in life insurance: the state of affairs (2017) — link
  7. Optimal surrender policy for variable annuity guarantees (2014) — link
  8. State-dependent fees for variable annuity guarantees (2014) — link
  9. Where less is more: reducing variable annuity fees to benefit policyholder and insurer (2019) — link
  10. Affine processes for dynamic mortality and actuarial valuations (2005) — link
  11. Time-Inconsistent Optimal Control Theory with Finance Applications (2021) — link
  12. Max-min optimization problem for variable annuities pricing (2015) — link
  13. Household ownership of variable annuities (2006) — link
  14. Optimal smooth consumption and annuity design (2013) — link
  15. A two-factor model for stochastic mortality with parameter uncertainty: theory and calibration (2006) — link
  16. Stackelberg differential game for insurance under model ambiguity (2022) — link
  17. Lectures on BSDEs , Stochastic Contorl and Stochastic Differential Games with Financial Applications (2016) — link
  18. Probabilistic Theory of Mean Field Games with Applications I (2018) — link
  19. The effect of modelling parameters on the value of GMWB guarantees (2008) — link
  20. A numerical scheme for the impulse control formulation for pricing variable annuities with a guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit (GMWB) (2008) — link
  21. On a new paradigm of optimal reinsurance: a stochastic Stackelberg differential game between an insurer and a reinsurer (2018) — link
  22. Stochastic Stackelberg differential reinsurance games under time-inconsistent mean-variance framework (2019) — link
  23. Variable annuities with high water mark withdrawal benefit (2016) — link
  24. Indifference fee rate for variable annuities (2016) — link
  25. Variable annuities with VIX -linked fee structure under a Heston -type stochastic volatility model (2017) — link
  26. Guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit in variable annuities (2008) — link
  27. Randomization and the valuation of guaranteed minimum death benefits (2023) — link
  28. Pricing and hedging of variable annuities with state-dependent fees (2014) — link
  29. Income drawdown option with minimum guarantee (2014) — link
  30. Research on lapse in life insurance: what has been done and what needs to be done? (2013) — link
  31. An Introduction to Computational Risk Management of Equity-Linked Insurance (2018)
  32. Variable annuity pricing, valuation, and risk management: a survey (2022) — link
  33. Optimal investment-withdrawal strategy for variable annuities under a performance fee structure (2025) — link
  34. An optimal stochastic control framework for determining the cost of hedging variable annuities (2014) — link
  35. Optimal allocation and consumption with guaranteed minimum death benefits, external income, and term life insurance (2015) — link
  36. Pricing of guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefits in variable annuities under stochastic volatility, stochastic interest rates and stochastic mortality via the componentwise splitting method (2019) — link
  37. Analytic valuation of guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefits with a modified ratchet (2024) — link
  38. Asset allocation and location over the life cycle with investment-linked survival-contingent payouts (2009) — link
  39. Optimal life cycle portfolio choice with variable annuities offering liquidity and investment downside protection (2015) — link
  40. Putting the pension back in 401(k) retirement plans: Optimal versus default deferred longevity income annuities (2020) — link
  41. Analysis of a penalty method for pricing a guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit ( GMWB ) (2012) — link
  42. Analysis of optimal withdrawal policies in withdrawal guarantee products (2014) — link
  43. Regression-based Monte Carlo methods for stochastic control models: variable annuities with lifelong guarantees (2016) — link
  44. Optimal initiation of guaranteed lifelong withdrawal benefit with dynamic withdrawals (2017) — link
  45. Pricing and hedging of guaranteed minimum benefits under regime-switching and stochastic mortality (2016) — link
  46. Pension and Annuity Income: For use in preparing 2016 returns (2016)
  47. Optimal surrender strategies and valuations of path-dependent guarantees in variable annuities (2018) — link
  48. Pricing variable annuity with surrender guarantee (2021) — link
  49. Variable annuities in Europe after the crisis: Blockbuster or niche product? (2010)
  50. Variable Annuities: A Global Perspective (2009)
  51. Optimal surrender of guaranteed minimum maturity benefits under stochastic volatility and interest rates (2018) — link
  52. Valuation of guaranteed minimum maturity benefits under generalised regime-switching models using the Fourier Cosine method (2022) — link
  53. Pricing and hedging variable annuities in a L'evy market: A risk management perspective (2015) — link
  54. Valuation and optimal surrender of variable annuities with guaranteed minimum benefits and periodic fees (2023)
  55. The impact of policyholder behavior on pricing, hedging, and hedge efficiency of withdrawal benefit guarantees in variable annuities (2014)
  56. VIX -linked fees for GMWB s via explicit solution simulation methods (2018) — link
  57. High-water mark fee structure in variable annuities (2021) — link
  58. Variable annuities (2008)
  59. Modeling and forecasting U.S. mortality (1992) — link
  60. From deterministic to stochastic surrender risk models: Impact of correlation crises on economic capital (2011)
  61. Optimal exercise of American puts with transaction costs under utility maximization (2022) — link
  62. Fast numerical method for pricing of variable annuities with guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit under optimal withdrawal strategy (2015) — link
  63. Risk management of policyholder behavior in equity-linked life insurance (2017)
  64. On an optimal stopping problem with a discontinuous reward — → 2311.03538
  65. Variable annuities and the option to seek risk: Why should you diversify? (2012) — link
  66. Risk minimizing portfolios and HJBI equations for stochastic differential games (2008)
  67. The Time-Discrete Method of Lines for Options and Bonds: A PDE Approach (2015) — link
  68. The valuation of American options with the method of lines (1997)
  69. Variable annuities versus mutual funds: a Monte - Carlo analysis of the options (2001)
  70. The real option to lapse a variable annuity: Can surrender charges complete the market? (2001)
  71. Financial valuation of guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefits (2006) — link
  72. MLC MasterKey Investment Protection (2025)
  73. Revisiting the risk-neutral approach to optimal policyholder behavior: a study of withdrawal guarantees in variable annuities (2016) — link
  74. Lapse-and-reentry in variable annuities (2018) — link
  75. Variable annuities: market incompleteness and policyholder behavior (2021) — link
  76. Taxation of a GMWB variable annuity in a stochastic interest rate model (2020) — link
  77. Unpredictable policyholder behavior challenges US life insurers’ variable annuity business (2013)
  78. OECD Pensions Outlook 2016 (2016) — link
  79. Post-tax optimization with stochastic programming (2004) — link
  80. Continuous-time Stochastic Control and Optimization with Financial Applications (2009) — link
  81. Germany Tax Guide 2016/2017 (2016)
  82. Valuation of guaranteed minimum maturity benefits in variable annuities with surrender options (2016) — link
  83. Pricing bounds and bang-bang analysis of the Polaris variable annuity (2020) — link
  84. A unified pricing of variable annuity guarantees under the optimal stochastic control framework (2016) — link
  85. Valuation of variable annuities with guaranteed minimum withdrawal benefit under stochastic interest rate (2017) — link
  86. Optimal Stochastic Control, Stochastic Target Problems, and Backward SDE (2013) — link
  87. Applied Stochastic Control of Jump Diffusions (2019) — link
  88. Stochastic Calculus for Finance II: Continuous-Time Models (2004)
  89. The effect of retirement taxation rules on the value of guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefits (2020) — link
  90. Analytic valuation of GMDB options with utility based asset allocation (2022) — link
  91. Optimal fee structure of variable annuities (2021) — link
  92. A leader-follower stochastic linear quadratic differential game (2002) — link
  93. Modeling the risk in mortality projections (2022) — link
  94. Variable annuities: A closer look at ratchet guarantees, hybrid contract designs, and taxation (2025) — link
  95. Applications received and approved (2025)
  96. Tax on super benefits (2023)
  97. Tax rates – Australian resident (2025)
  98. Calculating components of a super benefit (2025)
  99. Payments from super (2025)
  100. Investment income (2025)

1 of 108 cited works are in the corpus; resolved via arXiv source bundles, Semantic Scholar and OpenAlex. Corpus-wide: 2518 linked papers.